Talk:Mayim Achronim - Revision history

Iansimpson: /* Confusing */ new section

2023-10-13T22:36:41Z

Confusing: new section

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:36, 13 October 2023
Line 4:		Line 4:

	It was written poorly. I apologize. Now it is fixed. Yes, the Ben Ish Chai holds that it is better to use as little water as possible.		It was written poorly. I apologize. Now it is fixed. Yes, the Ben Ish Chai holds that it is better to use as little water as possible.

			== Confusing ==

			Sources 2 and 5 seem to contradict each other on what Shulchan Aruch holds. Later on when sourcing the order which people should wash it say that the Shulchan Aruch holds like himself. Please clarify thanks

YitzchakSultan at 17:59, 14 July 2014

2014-07-14T17:59:37Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:59, 14 July 2014
Line 2:		Line 2:

	I'm confused, am I to understand there is a chumrah to use LESS water by mayim achronim? What is the Ben Ish Chai saying when he says ''''''SHOULD''''' use less water'		I'm confused, am I to understand there is a chumrah to use LESS water by mayim achronim? What is the Ben Ish Chai saying when he says ''''''SHOULD''''' use less water'

			It was written poorly. I apologize. Now it is fixed. Yes, the Ben Ish Chai holds that it is better to use as little water as possible.

Joshs613: "Should use less water" according to Ben Ish Chai?

2014-07-13T23:42:07Z

"Should use less water" according to Ben Ish Chai?

New page

↑ Rashba Torah Bayit 6:2 that there’s no amount requirement, so says the Orchot Chaim Netilat Yadim 31, Kolbo 23 in name of Raavad. This is also the opinion of the Achronim such as Levush 181:7, Atret Zekinim 181:1, Shulchan Aruch Harav 181:4,Kaf Hachaim 181:4. The Mishna Brurah 181:19 says the practice of Gra was to use a Reviat, against the Chida Simchat Regel (Seder Birkat Hamazon) and Ben Ish Chai Shalach 8 who say one should use less water. Accordingly, says the Birur Halacha 181:13 if one’s hands are dirty one should first wash with intent that it’s not for Mayim Achronim and then rewash with intent with less water.

I'm confused, am I to understand there is a chumrah to use LESS water by mayim achronim? What is the Ben Ish Chai saying when he says ''''''SHOULD''''' use less water'